93 views (last 30 days)

Show older comments

I'm trying to fit beta distribution parameters to a [1X60] size vector (provided below as x) using betafit() funciton but the obtained parameters do not make sense (alpha=0.3840 beta= 23.4999), presenting a distribution which is far from representing the data. Nevertheless, by manually selecting the parameters (alpha=3 beta=3.5) I was managed to get a propper fit quite easily.

Is there any automated way to fit propper beta distribution parameters for this vector?

(I was able to simulate data from beta distribution and fit it successfully with this function, but from some reason the function is "not working" when applied to my data)

Thanks

The vector

x=[0.033280 0.049990 0.074000 0.082480 0.086050 0.082780 0.077200 0.067750 0.059840 0.053020 0.046540 0.041610 0.031640 0.027930 0.023980 0.021130 ...

0.018620 0.013620 0.011490 0.009930 0.008620 0.007670 0.005640 0.004970 0.004370 0.003880 0.003340 0.003230 0.002870 0.002580 0.002390 0.002180 ...

0.001490 0.001330 0.001160 0.001000 0.000920 0.000810 0.000730 0.000650 0.000570 0.000520 0.000450 0.000400 0.000370 0.000360 0.000310 0.000270

000290 0.000280 0.000260 0.000270 0.000240 0.000200 0.000160 0.000150 0.000130 0.000160 0.000820 0.001010];

The time vector

t=[0 0.0169491525423729 0.0338983050847458 0.0508474576271187 0.0677966101694915 0.0847457627118644 0.101694915254237 0.118644067796610 0.135593220338983 0.152542372881356 0.169491525423729 0.186440677966102 0.203389830508475 0.220338983050847 0.237288135593220 0.254237288135593 0.271186440677966 0.288135593220339 0.305084745762712 0.322033898305085 0.338983050847458 0.355932203389831 0.372881355932203 0.389830508474576 0.406779661016949 0.423728813559322 0.440677966101695 0.457627118644068 0.474576271186441 0.491525423728814 0.508474576271186 0.525423728813559 0.542372881355932 0.559322033898305 0.576271186440678 0.593220338983051 0.610169491525424 0.627118644067797 0.644067796610169 0.661016949152542 0.677966101694915 0.694915254237288 0.711864406779661 0.728813559322034 0.745762711864407 0.762711864406780 0.779661016949153 0.796610169491525 0.813559322033898 0.830508474576271 0.847457627118644 0.864406779661017 0.881355932203390 0.898305084745763 0.915254237288136 0.932203389830508 0.949152542372881 0.966101694915254 0.983050847457627 1];

Code line

betafit(x)

Output

ans =

0.3840 23.4999

Ive J
on 21 Feb 2021

I believe there is a misunderstanding here. betafit gives you MLE parameters best fitted to your x vector and not t.

x_new = linspace(min(x), max(x), 100);

pd = betafit(x);

yAutoFit = betapdf(x_new, pd(1), pd(1));

yManFit = betapdf(x_new, 2, 15);

histogram(x)

line(x_new, yAutoFit, 'color', 'k', 'LineWidth', 1.5)

line(x_new, yManFit, 'color', 'r', 'LineWidth', 1.5)

Jeff Miller
on 22 Feb 2021

There is information here about how to fit a univariate distribution from an empirical CDFs with MATLAB. Unfortunately, it is a bit complicated because the beta distribution belongs to the group of "Non-Location-Scale Families" discussed starting about half-way down the page.

x = x / sum(x); % normalize for sum to 1

ECDF = cumsum(x);

myBeta = Beta(1,1); % arbitrary starting parameters

myBeta.EstPctile(t,ECDF) % Estimate parameters from the ECDF, which produces estimates of 1.1889,7.985

myBeta.PlotDens

This produces the attached graph.

I don't think this is quite right, though, because I don't think the t values and probabilities correspond exactly. In particular, I doubt that you really have a probability of 0.033280 at exactly t=0, since that is the minimum for the beta distribution.

Noam Omer
on 21 Feb 2021

Jeff Miller
on 21 Feb 2021

Sorry, I misunderstood the original question. I thought x gave data values and did not realize they gave bin probabilities, with t defining the bin boundaries. betafit would only be appropriate with the data values, not the bin probabilities.

Since you have only bins and their probabilties, your best bet is to estimate from the empirical CDF:

But if the x values represent observed bin probabilities, why don't they sum to 1?

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!