Clear Filters
Clear Filters

vectorization of nested loop

1 view (last 30 days)
Fabricio
Fabricio on 19 Mar 2013
Hello,
I was wondering whether it is possible to make this following nested loop into a vectorization process to make things faster and more efficient.
Y= time series with one column with 10000 observations
[M N]=size(Y);
for INCREMENT=1:100
for WINDOW=1000:INCREMENT:M
for W=WINDOW:INCREMENT:M
BB{INCREMENT,WINDOW-999}(:,W-999)=Y(W-WINDOW+1:W);
end
end
end
Thank you for your time
  1 Comment
Daniel Shub
Daniel Shub on 19 Mar 2013
While you might be able to make those loops go faster with or without vectorization (try preallocating), you might want to think about how you are using BB. and why you want to hog so much memory by storing Y is a really inaccessible manner.

Sign in to comment.

Answers (1)

Jan
Jan on 19 Mar 2013
The code is not valid:
BB{INCREMENT,WINDOW-999}(W-999) = Y(W-WINDOW+1:W)
The lefthand side is a scalar, while the right hand side is a vector when WINDOW differs from 1.
The code will suffer from the missing pre-allocation. The Cell array BB and its contents will grow in each iteration, which will slow down the programm dramatically.
So currently the answer is: No. I cannot vectorize a crashing code.
  1 Comment
Fabricio
Fabricio on 19 Mar 2013
Sorry about the mistake, there's (:,W-999) rather than (W-999) Y= time series with one column with 10000 observations [M N]=size(Y); for INCREMENT=1:100 for WINDOW=1000:INCREMENT:M for W=WINDOW:INCREMENT:M BB{INCREMENT,WINDOW-999}(:,W-999)=Y(W-WINDOW+1:W); end end end
Do you think it's doable?

Sign in to comment.

Categories

Find more on Loops and Conditional Statements in Help Center and File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!