How does numArgumentsFromSubscript work?
Show older comments
As an exercise, I am trying to overload the subsref method in my user-defined class myclass to support the assignment expression,
[obj.X{:}] = deal(1,2,3)
The attached code succeeds in doing so, but as the tracing output shows, numArgumentsFromSubscript is called multiple times with identical inputs before subsasgn is ever reached.
obj=myclass();
[obj.X{:}] = deal(1,2,3)
Why is the second invocation of numArgumentsFromSubscript necessary and, more generally, what are the formal rules for when numArgumentsFromSubscript is called relative to subsref/subsasgn?
classdef myclass
properties
X (1,3) cell
end
methods
function obj=subsasgn(obj,S,varargin)
assert(strcmp(S(1).type,'.') && ...
strcmp(S(1).subs,'X'), 'Unrecognized syntax')
obj.X=builtin('subsasgn',obj.X,S(2:end),varargin{:});
disp("Executing subsasgn") %tracing
end
function n=numArgumentsFromSubscript(obj,S,indcon)
import matlab.indexing.IndexingContext
N=numel(S);
if N>1 && isequal(S(2).subs,{':'}) && indcon==IndexingContext.Assignment
n = numel(obj.X);
else
n = 1;
end
disp("numArgumentsFromSubscript with n="+n) %tracing
end
end
end
1 Comment
dpb
on 20 Jun 2026 at 19:40
Just for grins I looked at the m-code for the table incarnation and it internally sets a recursion level of two...
...
recurseAtLevel = 2;
% Perform one level of indexing,
% then forward result to builtin numArgumentsFromSubscript
Answers (0)
Categories
Find more on Customize Object Indexing in Help Center and File Exchange
Products
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!