plot using matlab(parabolic)
Show older comments
This is watt sepctrum equation, but i don't know why my plot is weired. The plot might be parabolic shape, but mine is not. Could you let me know what's the problem?
x = linspace(10,10^7);
y = 0.453 .* exp(-1.036 .* x) .* sinh((2.29.* x).^0.5);
plot(x,y);
Answers (2)
It IS curved, though not truly parabolic. A parabola means something specific about the shape, as a polynomial curve. But you just need to look carefully at what you have done. I'll do this for fewer points.
x = linspace(10,10^7,20)
y = 0.453 .* exp(-1.036 .* x) .* sinh((2.29.* x).^0.5)
So what happened? you had numerical problems. Do you see the NaNs there?
3 Comments
format long g
x = sym(linspace(10,10^7,20))
y = (0.453 .* exp(-1.036 .* x) .* sinh((2.29.* x).^0.5)).'
double(reshape(y,5,4))
Note the exp(negative of large large number)
format long g
-1317311753049245359/134217728000
exp() of negative 10 million is going to be tiny.
John D'Errico
on 25 Jan 2023
Edited: John D'Errico
on 25 Jan 2023
Sorry. I had to end that answer before I was really finished writing. The point is, you are going out as far as 1e7 in x. What happens when x is REALLY REALLY large?
x = 1e7;
exp(-1.036 .* x)
So that subexpression underflows. But what is
sinh((2.29.* x).^0.5)
And that term overflows. What is the product of 0*inf? That is an indeterminate expression. We could come up with entirely valid arguments that result should be 0, inf, or any finite number. Therefore MATLAb is forced to call it a NaN,
0*inf
Thus an indeterminate result. It has no value you can assign to it.
In fact, this happens even for relatively small values of x in that interval. Even 1e5 is far too large to let you see anything. I'm not sure whay you are starting at x==10, but you can see stuff happening out there.
x = linspace(10,30);
y = 0.453 .* exp(-1.036 .* x) .* sinh((2.29.* x).^0.5);
plot(x,y)
As I said, this is not at all parabolic.
x = linspace(0.1,5,100); % may be parabolic
y = 0.453 .* exp(-1.036 .* x) .* sinh((2.29.* x).^0.5);
plot(x,y);
Parabolic probably depends on what range of parameter values you consider in the equation
Categories
Find more on Spline Postprocessing in Help Center and File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!


