Is there a way to guaranteed floating point accuracy between MATLAB and SIMULINK?
Show older comments
I run the same code in MATLAB and SIMULINK (MATLAB Embedded Block) and at times get slightly different results. I notice it is because of floating point accuracy where at times I may get a 1e-30 difference in a calculation and then that propagates through. I've read a little about variable precision arithmetic but it isn't supported in code generation for SIMULINK. So I am stuck with a problem where I cannot reliably produce the same answers in two environments using the same initial conditions and algorithm.
Answers (1)
Sebastian Castro
on 21 Sep 2015
0 votes
The discrepance should depend on the numerical solver you are using in MATLAB vs. Simulink. This includes the type of solver, step-size options, tolerances, and so on.
For example, if you are using variable-step solvers like ode45, you should match the model configuration parameters against the odeset options in the programmatic approach.
If you configure them to be identical to each other, the results should match up too.
- Sebastian
5 Comments
Thomas Marullo
on 22 Sep 2015
Edited: Thomas Marullo
on 22 Sep 2015
John D'Errico
on 22 Sep 2015
No, because there are many possible solvers, with many possible options.
Walter Roberson
on 22 Sep 2015
Even if exactly the same solvers were used with the same configuration, unless the exact same code is used, the values can be different.
Thomas Marullo
on 24 Sep 2015
Walter Roberson
on 24 Sep 2015
Your other question about this dealt with calling the same inv() routine, on the same data, so the explanation for it is something different, such as the state of the floating point rounding controls.
Categories
Find more on General Applications in Help Center and File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!