FFT gives different answers according to what axis its applied to

4 views (last 30 days)
I am seeing some behaviour with fft which I did not expect. It appears the output of the FFT depends on the axis to which it is applied.
In the following example - doing the FFT of the same data vector differs depending on whether you do fft, axis 1, data (100,1) compared to doing fft on axis 2 with the data shaped (1,100). I would expect these to be the same?
r = randn(100,1);
rf = fft(r);
rf1 = fft(r,[],1);
rt = r';
rtf = fft(rt,[],2);
Even more worrying - ifft behaves the same way, so when reconstructing the original random array:
irf = ifft(rf);
irtf = ifft(rtf'); % this doesn't match irf
irtf2 = ifft(rtf,[],2); % this does match irf
Shouldn't irtf and irtf2 be the same? This seems quite dangerous to me - I thought it is standard to transpose data as required in Matlab and I would not expect to see differences in the output here.

Accepted Answer

Guillaume on 20 Feb 2015
Edited: Guillaume on 20 Feb 2015
The results are the same. Your problem is with the usage of ' aka ctranspose which computes the conjugate transpose of the input, i.e. not only transpose the vector but returns the conjugate of complex values.
To just do a plain transpose use the dotted version .' aka transpose:
r = randn(100, 1);
isequal(fft(r), fft(r, [], 1)) %return true
isequal(fft(r), fft(r.', [], 2).') %return true
edit: d'oh. Got my demo wrong!

More Answers (1)

Thomas Koelen
Thomas Koelen on 20 Feb 2015
Edited: Thomas Koelen on 20 Feb 2015
fft behaves the same in:
close all
clear all
Try this.


Find more on Creating and Concatenating Matrices in Help Center and File Exchange


Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!