How can I raise an anonymous expression to a power?
Show older comments
I am trying to replicate the quotient rule for finding derivatives using anonymous functions. I cannot figure out a way to raise one anonymous function to a power for this to work. Here is what I have
syms x
f1 = @(x) (x+1).*(x-3);
g1 = @(x) x.^3 + 2.*x +1;
h = @(x) f1(x)./g1(x);
df1dx = diff(@(x) f1(x), x);
dg1dx = diff(@(x) g1(x), x);
dhdx = diff(@(x) h(x), x);
simplify(dhdx)
% The below line does not work, and I cannt figure out why...
quotient = (f1.*dg1dx - df1dx.*g1) / (g1).^2;
simplify(quotient)
How can I use a power with this function?
1 Comment
Dustin
on 16 Jun 2014
Edited: Star Strider
on 16 Jun 2014
Answers (2)
Rashmil Dahanayake
on 9 Jun 2014
Edited: Rashmil Dahanayake
on 9 Jun 2014
Firstly correct the definition the inline functions for differentiation. Start the command with @ symbol. When calling inline functions you must pass an argument. eg F(x).
Updated code
syms x
f1 = @(x) (x+1).*(x-3);
g1 = @(x) x.^3 + 2.*x +1;
h = @(x) f1(x)./g1(x);
df1dx = @(x) diff(f1(x), x); % note the location of @ symbol
dg1dx =@(x) diff(g1(x), x);
dhdx = @(x) diff(h(x), x);
simplify(dhdx(x)) % pass an argument to the function
quotient = (f1(x).*dg1dx(x) - df1dx(x).*g1(x)) / (g1(x)).^2;
simplify(quotient)
Star Strider
on 9 Jun 2014
Edited: Star Strider
on 9 Jun 2014
The Symbolic Toolbox will work with anonymous functions, but it prefers not to, because anonymous functions prefer numeric inputs.
‘Undefined function 'power' for input arguments of type 'function_handle'.’
Try this instead:
syms x
f1(x) = (x+1).*(x-3);
g1(x) = x.^3 + 2.*x +1;
h(x) = f1(x)./g1(x);
df1dx = diff(f1(x), x);
dg1dx = diff(g1(x), x);
dhdx = diff(h(x), x);
simplify(dhdx)
% The below line does not work, and I cannt figure out why...
% (It does now!)
quotient = (f1.*dg1dx - df1dx.*g1) / (g1).^2;
quotient = simplify(collect(quotient))
% Compare:
quotient2 = diff(f1/g1, x);
quotient2 = simplify(collect(quotient2))
Not surprisingly, the same answer.
If you want to use anonymous functions outside of the Symbolic Math Toolbox to calculate numeric derivatives, it‘s easy enough:
dfdx = @(f,x) (f(x+1E-8)-f(x)) ./ 1E-8; % Generic derivative function
f = @(x) x.^2; % Function to differentiate
x = 0:5; % Evaluate function & derivative
fx = f(x)
dfx = dfdx(f,x)
produces:
fx =
0.0000e+000 1.0000e+000 4.0000e+000 9.0000e+000 16.0000e+000 25.0000e+000
dfx =
10.0000e-009 2.0000e+000 4.0000e+000 6.0000e+000 8.0000e+000 10.0000e+000
With your functions:
f1 = @(x) (x+1).*(x-3);
g1 = @(x) x.^3 + 2.*x +1;
quotnt = f1(x)./g1(x)
dquotnt1 = (f1(x).*dfdx(g1,x) - dfdx(f1,x).*g1(x)) ./ (g1(x)).^2
dquotnt2 = dfdx(@(x) f1(x)./g1(x),x)
The result produced by dquotnt1 is negative. The dquotnt2 expression gives the correct result.
Categories
Find more on Calculus in Help Center and File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!